Midnight - Erin Hunter I found this particular book not to be as good as the previous books. It wasn't that it was bad so much as it was harder to like the characters. Firestar turns from a likeable character to very rigid, angry, and all around unpleasant. The only character I found to be likeable were Leafpaw and Cinderpaw, and that's because Leafpaw resembled Firestar in previous books and Cinderpaw mostly stayed the same.